ascension of the red star of sauron when earedil is already in the heavens the influence of earendil cannot be underestimated the silmaril of earendil is forever (beyond?) grasp but the remaining two must be recoverable feanors writings themselves be accessible in rivendell if a way could be devised gain time (among?) elronds chambers elronds library is rumoured to be far more extensive even than that of minas tirith